Service Center / Claims
Few people enjoy the unknown. Fewer still enjoy being involved in accidents.
If you’ve been involved in an accident – or feel you need to file a claim – please feel free to either call us or fill out our online claim form. An agent will contact you shortly. Claims will be monitored Monday thru Friday 9am-5pm. If you have a claim outside of this timeframe and cannot reach us or require a rapid response, please contact your insurance company directly.
If this is an emergency, please call 911.
Claim Phone Numbers:
- Aegis Insurance Company (800) 233-2160
- American Modern Home (800) 375-2075
- Bristol West (800) 274-7865
- Dairyland Insurance Company (Sentry Insurance) (800) 274-7865
- Donegal Mutual (800) 877-9006
- Encompass Insurance (800) 588-7400
- Farmers Insurance Group (800) 435-7764
- Fireman's Fund Insurance Company (800) 446-1677
- Foremost Insurance Group (800) 527-3907
- GMAC Insurance Company (800) 526-0332
- Grundy, JC Taylor & Hagerty (800) 338-4005
- Keystone National Insurance Company 888-544-5642
- Motorist Mutual Insurance Company 866-542-9405
- Ohio Casualty Insurance (866) 255-5530
- Penn National Insurance 800-942-9715
- Progressive Insurance Group 800-776-4737
- SAFECO (800) 332-3226
- Travelers (800) 252-4633
- Westfield Group (866) 937-2663
For Workers Compensation Claims, please contact your insurance company directly.
Zenith: 800-440-5020
Ohio: 866-255-5530
Penn National: 800-374-4990
Lackawanna: 888-280-5225





